Windows Server 2012 Resource Centre
[ad] Windows Server 2012 redefines the server category, delivering hundreds of new features and enhancements spanning virtualization, networking, storage, user experience, cloud computing, automation, and more. Click here to visit our Windows Server 2012 Resource Centre with case studies, white papers and articles about Windows Server 2012.
Nokia Lumia Smartphones: Innovation's calling
[ad] Nokia Lumia with Windows Phone comes with unique camera technology, wireless charging and turn-by-turn navigation. Make every image picture perfect. See your city differently. Charge without wires. Click here to learn more.
Save up to $199 on Dell XPS 12 Ultrabooks: Power for your projects and passions.
[ad] This convertible Ultrabook™ delivers the speed and performance you expect from the XPS family in a sleek new design that's ready for work and play. Don't get two pieces of technology when one will do it all. The Dell XPS 12 is a tablet and Ultrabook combined to produce the perfect laptop.
Great articles on other sites
- $5.2m to put e-tax on Mac
- Galaxy S 4 “Google Edition” to be available in Australia via MobiCity
- When does mission creep become censorship?
- First NBN fibre extension completed
- Proof the internet filter lives on by other means
- Budget 2013: Heavy on 'showcasing', light on strategy
- CGU to replace core insurance system
- Google Australia calls for mandatory comp sci until year 10
- Spectrum fail could help Libs fight Labor's regional NBN
- Offended By Fraudband? Maybe You Shouldn’t Have Said It First
Managing virtualised environments: Free whitepaper
[ad] Virtualisation is one of the single most important technologies for efficiently operating servers. This free whitepaper presents information about current trends in virtualisation adoption, risks associated with single vendor virtualisation, and the benefits of open source virtualisation. Click here to download the whitepaper.
One More Thing - iOS App Maker Conference - 24th May
[ad] If you make iOS apps, come listen to the best in the industry share their tip & tricks for App Store success. Melbourne, 24th May, 2013 - use the coupon code "delimiter" for 5% off.
Telecommunications - Written by Renai LeMay on Tuesday, October 11, 2011 9:22 - 22 Comments
Quoting the Economist belies Turnbull’s intelligence
On last night’s Q&A program on the ABC, an audience member asked a somewhat controversial question of the panel, which included writers, a lawyer and representatives from both sides of politics. “Steve Jobs was an innovator, above all a visionary. President Obama said in a tribute: He was brave enough to think differently. Who in the Australian political scene today, do you think is or could be the innovator, the visionary, who is brave enough to be different?” asked questioner Peter Edwick.
From memory, the initial answer was “nobody”, but of course Assistant Treasurer Bill Shorten loyally raised Julia Gillard as the nation’s biggest political visionary. Deputy Leader of the Opposition Julie Bishop, in turn, raised Tony Abbott, comparing the Liberal leader’s tenacity to that of Jobs. At the time I almost choked on my Heineken. Abbott — it must be said — is no Steve Jobs.
And at one point the name “Malcolm Turnbull” was briefly mentioned, to general interest and some laughter from the room.
It had been something I was expecting to happen. If you ask the man on the street in Sydney which politician they most respect — an experiment I often perform in taxis — the name of the current Shadow Communications Minister and former Liberal leader often comes up. Like Jobs, Turnbull has been an entrepreneur (think OzEmail), but he also has a wider vision; encompassing climate change, Australia’s situation in Asia, the economy and more.
In these days where our political leaders seem locked into a cycle of pointless debate on issues few people care about, Turnbull’s approach often feels like a breath of fresh air. That’s why I was so disappointed to see the Member for Wentworth yesterday drawing from yet another spurious grab-bag of flawed statistics from an already discredited source — the Economist Intelligence Unit — to criticise the government on broadband.
Many among you will remember the ease with which Communications Minister Stephen Conroy demolished the last piece of NBN research produced by the Economist. In February this year, Conroy highlighted the glaring factual inaccuracies in a report by the magazine on the NBN, labelling the document as “right-wing dogma”.
At the time, I found it hard to disagree with him.
Yesterday, Turnbull made his first public appearance in Australia after spending time in Europe, where he met with telcos and their regulators in countries like the UK. He used the occasion to highlight a new report by the Economist, which claims the Federal Government is “extravagant” in its spending on the NBN — even more so than the “next most lavish spender”, Greece — a nation on the edge of financial disaster.
“The reaction around the world to the NBN is as was very elegantly, if not diplomatically, summed up to me by one very senior official in Europe last week: ‘From our point of view, your policy seems completely crazy, Mr Turnbull’,” said Turnbull yesterday. “Well of course, it’s not my policy, it’s Mr Conroy’s policy and it is a disgrace to Australia.”
Now, there is no doubt that Turnbull has achieved his aim in commenting on the Economist’s report. An AAP article on the subject has already been published around Australia by dozens of media outlets. The MP has made his point: The Federal Government is spending more money on telecommunications than other governments are.
And yet we can’t help but be fascinated by little-reported comments by NBN Co this week that point out — yet again — that the Economist’s research is seriously flawed in its analysis of the NBN. The Age reports:
“A spokeswoman for NBN Co said the report underestimated the number of households that would be connected by 6 million, and did not recognise the company would make a commercial return.”
And on Twitter, NBN Co spokesperson Andrew Sholl reiterated the point: The Economist report underestimated by 50 percent the number of premises that would be connected. Sholl appends the hashtag #dodgymethodology — and we find it hard to disagree that that appendage is appropriate. And then on Twitter again this morning, NBN Co struck back stronger against the Economist:
“The Economist survey claimed the #NBN will cover 7.45m Australian premises in fact it will cover 13m+ premises by the time it is complete. You have to question a report that seems to have mislaid millions of homes and businesses. It overlooked that Australia is more than 3x the size of all the other top-ranked countries combined and that the #NBN will pay itself back.”
Now, I have no doubt that Malcolm Turnbull is well-read. I have no doubt that he is highly educated, and that he has a way with words which leads to catchy soundbites such as comparing Stephen Conroy and his NBN project to Communist Cuba. This sort of thing makes for great article headlines.
But Steve Jobs, as we have heard repetitively over the past few weeks, didn’t believe in doing market research before developing Apple products. He anticipated and created consumer demand — he didn’t discover it. If Turnbull truly wants to be known as an innovator and a visionary in Australian politics, he must stop clutching at every half-baked twig that passes his way as evidence that the NBN is flawed policy, and start swimming for himself.
Image credit: Office of Malcolm Turnbull
Leave a Comment
Blog, Enterprise IT - May 23, 2013 13:03 - 0 Comments
More In Enterprise IT
- Victoria abandons IT shared services?
Core CenITex services to be outsourced
- Australia gets two Windows Azure datacentres
- Oracle reveals swathe of Aussie rollouts
- Australia’s universities hacked on a regular basis
- 32 years later, CGU replaces insurance IT platform
News, Telecommunications - May 23, 2013 11:57 - 77 Comments
More In Telecommunications
- Telstra set for massive internal restructure
- iiNet sells TransACT’s FTTP to NBN Co
- At death’s door:
Vodafone loses 216k more customers
- 4G race: Telstra turns on 1500th tower
- Optus launches TD-LTE 4G trial in Canberra
Blog, Gadgets, Gaming - May 23, 2013 14:28 - 16 Comments
More In Gadgets
- Sony Xperia Z tablet hits Australia
- HP Slate 7 to land in Australia shortly
- Why touchscreens matter for laptops
(Or, review of the ThinkPad X1 Carbon Touch)
- Amazon Appstore challenging Google Play as Australian launch looms
- Consoles to suffer as tablets triple mobile games downloads by 2017