This article was originally published for Delimiter Members only. In late September 2016, Delimiter ceased publishing new articles. Because of a number of operational and other factors associated with this decision, we subsequently withdrew membership articles from publication. If you would like to see a copy of this article, please contact Delimiter directly with your request. Requests by Delimiter Members will be granted. We will consider all other requests on their merits.
I suggest this is a clever move by the Liberals. To compensate for the reduced CVC revenue, AVC pricing will need to either rise or not fall (as planned by Labor). This means that faster plans will be more expensive driving down demand for faster speeds providing further justification for MTM.
Higher AVC prices mean less people connecting to the NBN and connecting at slower speeds.
Well Mathew why shouldnt it fall Malcolm said is avc price would start at $16
Why Mathew should people on FTTN pay the same Avc price as someone on FTTP when it cost cheaper to connect them. Are they in fact paying for people getting FTTP.
I can copy/paste too…
“So let me get this straight Mathew…
You believe it’s very clever by the “Liberals (not NBN™ *sigh*) the Liberals” – got it… to, if the demand for speeds are there, quash them and quash them now… to show shitty MTM is best?
Seriously WTF… did you just support that?
Oh you weren’t supporting it just sayin’? I see…
Ok well in that case, tell us about the 4 year hold ups and almost tripling in price (to $70B according to the former Treasurer) of the “Liberals (see what I did there)” complete fuck up MTM plan, instead of harping on and on about one or two WGAF estimations from “Labor” (and see what I did there too) in 2010 then.
Ata boy.
Why are you limiting the discussion to FTTN when the same problems with congestion are also impacting FTTP?
I did mention FTTP in the article.
But the problems have been most acutely felt on the early FTTN network.
Please point to a single example of where a FTTP user has found peak speeds of single digit Mbps outside of the Optus network.
@ Hotcakes,
Refer to Nick’s post.
Besides, you shouldn’t rely on anecdotal evidence. You need statistics to show that congestion is more acutely felt on FTTN. Where is that hard evidence?
Btw, if you misdiagnose a problem then you’ll never be able to fix it.
How convenient for you that that should appear for the first time in 3 years just AFTER I posted that request.
You must have looked in the mirror and said nope, nope, nope did you HC… ?
And lo and behold…look what appeared…
:/
You need statistics to show that congestion is more acutely felt on FTTN.
Congestion will never be noticed on FttN, it’s slow already.
Some users on FTTN are reporting speeds that are less than they have on adsl 2.
One user’s fttn connection drops out 27 times a day.
Lets face it – the MTM is a dud – just like the prime minister.
can concur, i get 2-3mbps at peak periods at night on FTTP 100mbps plan with iinet
NBNco will only accept a fault after running 4 tests 3 times a day for 72 hours.
pathetic
Not surprise, iiNet have usually been good with ADSL2+ exchanges where they have their own fibre, but the cheapskates don’t like paying for backhaul otherwise. They would also strenuously deny it. I remember Malone denying lack of backhaul, while his techs were calling me privately so they weren’t recorded to let me know he that iiNet had only provisioned minimal backhaul in that case. I guess the same goes for CVC. Not like it’s going to get better with TPG owning them.
Why not take your business to another ISP?
Indeed Greg. That’s one of the strengths of the NBN model, multiple RSP’s on the same network…
Shame the LPA didn’t think of that when they flogged Telstra off as a “free market” monopoly.
NBN has no such limitation. that’s something your ISP is imposing on you.
ask your ISP to supply details of peak hour CVC utilisation to you to prove their CVC is not the cause of your issues. (protip – they won’t.) alternatively, go and ask someone else in your street (that uses a different ISP) if they have the same issues. (they won’t.)
if your ISP is underprovisioning their CVC capacity, stop rewarding them with your business and churn.
“Now what’s going to happen here is because there is no competition, because this is a government monopoly and because they are spending so much money so they’re overcapitalising it, inevitably prices are going to be high.” — Malcolm Turnbull, 1 February 2012.
I suggest this is a clever move by the Liberals. To compensate for the reduced CVC revenue, AVC pricing will need to either rise or not fall (as planned by Labor). This means that faster plans will be more expensive driving down demand for faster speeds providing further justification for MTM.
Higher AVC prices mean less people connecting to the NBN and connecting at slower speeds.
Well Mathew why shouldnt it fall Malcolm said is avc price would start at $16
Why Mathew should people on FTTN pay the same Avc price as someone on FTTP when it cost cheaper to connect them. Are they in fact paying for people getting FTTP.
I can copy/paste too…
“So let me get this straight Mathew…
You believe it’s very clever by the “Liberals (not NBN™ *sigh*) the Liberals” – got it… to, if the demand for speeds are there, quash them and quash them now… to show shitty MTM is best?
Seriously WTF… did you just support that?
Oh you weren’t supporting it just sayin’? I see…
Ok well in that case, tell us about the 4 year hold ups and almost tripling in price (to $70B according to the former Treasurer) of the “Liberals (see what I did there)” complete fuck up MTM plan, instead of harping on and on about one or two WGAF estimations from “Labor” (and see what I did there too) in 2010 then.
Ata boy.
Why are you limiting the discussion to FTTN when the same problems with congestion are also impacting FTTP?
I did mention FTTP in the article.
But the problems have been most acutely felt on the early FTTN network.
Please point to a single example of where a FTTP user has found peak speeds of single digit Mbps outside of the Optus network.
@ Hotcakes,
Refer to Nick’s post.
Besides, you shouldn’t rely on anecdotal evidence. You need statistics to show that congestion is more acutely felt on FTTN. Where is that hard evidence?
Btw, if you misdiagnose a problem then you’ll never be able to fix it.
How convenient for you that that should appear for the first time in 3 years just AFTER I posted that request.
You must have looked in the mirror and said nope, nope, nope did you HC… ?
And lo and behold…look what appeared…
:/
Congestion will never be noticed on FttN, it’s slow already.
iiNet have a lot of complaints on FTTP: https://www.reddit.com/r/perth/comments/4dwwy2/fttp_nbn_in_east_vic_park/ http://iispeed.ddns.net/
Because it effects FTTN far more than FTTP.
Some users on FTTN are reporting speeds that are less than they have on adsl 2.
One user’s fttn connection drops out 27 times a day.
Lets face it – the MTM is a dud – just like the prime minister.
can concur, i get 2-3mbps at peak periods at night on FTTP 100mbps plan with iinet
NBNco will only accept a fault after running 4 tests 3 times a day for 72 hours.
pathetic
Not surprise, iiNet have usually been good with ADSL2+ exchanges where they have their own fibre, but the cheapskates don’t like paying for backhaul otherwise. They would also strenuously deny it. I remember Malone denying lack of backhaul, while his techs were calling me privately so they weren’t recorded to let me know he that iiNet had only provisioned minimal backhaul in that case. I guess the same goes for CVC. Not like it’s going to get better with TPG owning them.
Why not take your business to another ISP?
Indeed Greg. That’s one of the strengths of the NBN model, multiple RSP’s on the same network…
Shame the LPA didn’t think of that when they flogged Telstra off as a “free market” monopoly.
NBN has no such limitation. that’s something your ISP is imposing on you.
ask your ISP to supply details of peak hour CVC utilisation to you to prove their CVC is not the cause of your issues. (protip – they won’t.) alternatively, go and ask someone else in your street (that uses a different ISP) if they have the same issues. (they won’t.)
if your ISP is underprovisioning their CVC capacity, stop rewarding them with your business and churn.
— Malcolm Turnbull, 1 February 2012.
Comments are closed.