[ad] The service leader for Cloud is now in Australia. Secure, reliable cloud and managed hosting all backed by 24x7x365 Fanatical Support. Create your free account now.
Buy an Seagate Business Storage NAS for your chance to win a holiday
[ad] Purchase a selected Seagate Business Storage NAS to receive a $20 cash-back AND go into the draw to win a $1,000 Flight Centre voucher so you can holiday in the destination of your choice. T&Cs apply.
Great articles on other sites
- Xbox One smashes sales records
- Tech leaders call for speed, ubiquity in NBN rollout
- AIIA urges Hockey to tackle taxes
- IBM accuses Qld govt of trying to ‘rewrite history’
- Newlease undergoes reverse takeover to score ASX listing
- Australia Post loses battle | The Australian
- Start-ups leap at Telstra's accelerator
- Labor won't hand over NBN advice to Turnbull
- Adelaide Uni on hiring blitz for tech transformation
- Human Services to cut 56 IT jobs
How mobile and social media affect your Customer Experience strategy
[ad] How will the adoption of mobile devices and social media affect your Customer Experience strategy? Are you reaching your organisation's customers through these touch points? Click here to download a whitepaper by Fifth Quadrant examining consumer and business attitudes to these new contact channels.
50 things top IT pros need to know
[ad] This 18 page TechRepublic whitepaper explores 10 things you should know to become an epic IT manager, 40 other essential tips to advance your IT career and practical guidance for starting an IT consulting business. Click here to access the whitepaper.
News, Telecommunications - Written by Renai LeMay on Wednesday, May 2, 2012 9:56 - 123 Comments
Copper maintenance cost not an issue, says Turnbull
news Upgrading Telstra’s copper network to fibre to the node was the “quickest and easiest” way to get better broadband for Australians, the office of Shadow Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull said this week, highlighting a study which had shown that the cost of maintaining the decades-old infrastructure was not significant compared with the overall investment required for universal fibre.
Yesterday Delimiter published a photo gallery of the “worst of the worst” aspects of Telstra’s copper network, which was first constructed gradually over the past century. The photos show that in many cases the network has not been adequately maintained, with many aspects of it open to the elements or in obvious need of repair. Currently, the network is slated to eventually be scrapped and replaced by optic fibre infrastructure under Labor’s National Broadband Network plan, but the Coalition is proposing to re-use portions of Telstra’s network under a modified plan to run fibre only part of the way to end users’ premises, in a rollout style known as “fibre to the node”.
In a response to the photo gallery, a spokesperson from Turnbull’s office said the Coalition’s policy was to be “technologically agnostic”, so it wouldn’t rule out using one technology or another.
“We recognise that in some areas, the cost of maintaining or upgrading the copper will make it uneconomic to upgrade,” they added. “But the experience around the world by telcos is that there has been a lot of investment in upgrading the copper because that is the quickest and most efficient means of upgrading broadband.”
The spokesperson said that on a recent trip to the United States, Turnbull had learnt that major telco AT&T had opted for a fibre to the node approach to upgrading its broadband network, taking the view that there was “no technical need” to go to the NBN’s fibre to the premise-style rollout in most areas where the copper network already existed.
“BT in the UK takes a similar approach. The technology is moving quickly and the right approach is one which combines a rigorous cost effective approach with an open minded attitude to technology,” they said.
The spokesperson also forwarded Delimiter comments Turnbull made to a recent conference in April, where the Liberal MP extensively commented on the cost of maintaining Telstra’s copper network.
At the time, Turnbull acknowledged that some advocated for the FTTH option had stated that costs for network maintenance, fault remediation and provisioning were lower with fibre, with US telco Verizon stating that eventual reductions as large as 80 to 90 percent could be possible, assuming a fully fibre network (compared with a copper network). Research house Analysys Mason had also analysed the issue, he said, finding that in the long term, the cost of operating a FTTH network could be in the region of 30 percent lower than the costs of operating the current copper network.
However, according to Turnbull, Analysys Mason also found that in the short-term, the total operating costs may increase due to the inefficiencies of operating parallel fibre- and copper-based networks, as Telstra and NBN Co will do for some time while the NBN is being rolled out.
In addition, the analyst firm found that the “the magnitude of the savings in operating costs is relatively small when compared to the overall investment required. In the case of [FTTN], therefore, the available savings are unlikely to be sufficient to make a business case unattractive; for [FTTH] the savings are likely to be substantially less than would be required to fund the investment based solely on savings in operating costs.”
Personally, I really don’t understand the argument that Turnbull is making here. Yesterday I sent his office an email asking him, given the somewhat shocking photos we published, whether Telstra’s copper network represented infrastructure worth upgrading to a fibre to the node-style deployment. In return, I got this complex economic analysis.
It’s important to note that at this stage, discussion over the cost of rolling out the National Broadband Network is somewhat moot. The network is slated to make a modest return on investment over the long term; hence it will not cost taxpayers money and is not an expense; in fact, it is an investment which will make money. This return is virtually guaranteed by the fact that there will be no fixed infrastructure competing with the NBN’s fibre (with Telstra’s copper network to be shut down and the Telstra and Optus HFC cable networks to stop providing broadband).
If the Coalition has analysis showing that the NBN will not make a return, then it should present that evidence. Until it does, we can only rely on the information we have right now, which shows the NBN will make a return.
With this in mind, the discussion about the NBN should now be turning purely to technical grounds. And on technical grounds, which I was trying to get at with the photo gallery I published yesterday, there really is no comparison between FTTN, which will partially rely on Telstra’s often-dodgy copper infrastructure, and the NBN’s FTTH style of rollout, which will completely replace it. Those awful shots of network infrastructure we published yesterday? All of those cables and terminating units will be ripped out and replaced with brand new gear under the NBN.
Unlike some commentators, I do feel the FTTN model has merit, and I agree with Turnbull that it would still meet many of the aims that both the Coalition and Labor hold with respect to delivering fast broadband to Australia. Personally, I’d love to have FTTN rolled out to my house, as it would deliver an instant speed and reliability boost over teh current copper network.
But I don’t feel that the Coalition has yet done enough to make its argument yet for FTTN; I’d like to see it try harder to justify its preference for this style of rollout. Labor’s NBN policy is a complex and highly evolved platform which the Coalition has not yet matched with its own plans. Before we start tearing down Labor’s vision, we need to see more detail about what it could be replaced with.
Image credit: Office of Malcolm Turnbull
Latest Delimiter 2.0 articles (subscriber content)
|Politicians from Australia’s major parties need to stop issuing ludicrous blanket pardons for the intelligence community’s ongoing misdemeanours and start applying a basic modicum of transparency and accountability to this important national security function.|
|The independent pro-fibre National Broadband Network movement is doing a far better job of promoting Labor’s Fibre to the Premises-based NBN policy than Labor itself. When is Labor going to wake from its slumber and start supporting this scrappy but energetic grassroots network of activists?|
|Ziggy Switkowski's first substantial public appearance since being appointed NBN Co chief executive has starkly demonstrated just how different he is from his predecessor, Mike Quigley, and just how strictly he will adhere to the guidelines which his patron, Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull, has set for him.|
|Australian technology companies have been virtually absent from the the nation’s public stockmarket over the past decade as the stigma of the dot com bust took its toll on investor confidence. But a clutch of new listings planned for the closing months of 2013 shows renewed interest in the sector and that local entrepreneurs are smelling money in the air once again.|
|NBN Co’s Strategic Review process gives the company an unmissable opportunity to re-evaluate the early decision to deploy its FTTP network primarily through Telstra’s underground ducts. The company and its new Coalition masters must now seriously consider deploying more fibre aerially on power poles in an effort to speed up its rollout substantially.|
|That moment which many Australian technologists fervently hoped for but never expected to see has come to pass: Simon Hackett has been appointed to the board of the National Broadband Network Company. But what questions should the Internode founder be asking NBN Co’s executive management team? Here’s five ideas to start with.|
|The rapid replacement of respected NBN Co chief operating officer Ralph Steffens with a Telstra executive who appears less experienced with fibre rollouts but better politically connected represents a key signal that NBN Co’s senior executive hiring process has now become completely politicised and is no longer independent from the Federal Government.|
Enterprise IT, News - Dec 10, 2013 17:23 - 2 Comments
More In Enterprise IT
- David Boyle appointed NAB CIO
- Qld payroll lawsuit ‘rewriting history’, says IBM
- Harbour City Ferries goes Microsoft across the board
- Payroll disaster: Queensland sues IBM
- End of an era: Oracle Australia’s ‘safe hands’ leaves
News, Telecommunications - Dec 10, 2013 18:16 - 12 Comments
More In Telecommunications
- Telstra 4G trials hit 300Mbps
- “Captain of the Titanic”: Turnbull mocks Quigley’s NBN tenure
- NBN Co still has 1Gbps on way
- Delimiter appeals Turnbull Blue Book censorship
- Final closure: TPG buys AAPT for $450m
Blog, Industry, Startups - Dec 10, 2013 10:19 - 0 Comments
More In Industry
- Telstra shares millions with Box
- The Australian IT sector needs a stronger voice
- Xbox One goes off with a bang … but will the PS4 launch eclipse it?
- It’s not just Freelancer: Aussie tech IPOs are back in general
- Freelancer’s IPO: A billion reasons to care
Digital Rights, News - Dec 10, 2013 18:57 - 0 Comments
More In Digital Rights
- Telstra ‘not logging’ customers’ web, email history
- Labor, Coalition reject Intelligence committee reformation
- Screwed: Australian PS4, Xbox One lack basic functionality
- Censored: Appeal for AG’s Blue Book fails
- Senate to force TPP publication