review Following Apple’s presentation of the iPhone 4S a couple of weeks ago, we were pretty impressed at how clever the new Siri technology was. For those that haven’t been lapping up all the iPhone 4S coverage lately, Siri is Apple’s new (well, ‘acquired’ would be more accurate) voice-controlled artificial intelligence technology that’s exclusive to the iPhone 4S.
After using it over the weekend, however, we’re not really feeling the Siri love. In fact, we’re feeling a little gypped. Aussie Siri, as it turns out, isn’t as smart as the American Siri, as it can’t look up local businesses, maps or traffic. This rules out a large portion of Siri’s capabilities; commands like “I’m hungry”, “I’ve run out of petrol” or “my computer is broken”, which should return results for the nearest businesses that can help with those concerns, are met with a “I can only look for businesses in the United States, and when you’re using US English. Sorry about that”.
What’s annoying is that Apple doesn’t make this limitation clear. Its description for Siri on the Australian website is different to the one on the US website in that most of the references to business- or location-related queries have been removed, but some are still there. There’s a reference to “Location Services” that “looks up where you live, where you work and where you are. Then it gives you information and the best options based on your current location”. There’s also a screenshot of Siri returning results based on a query for Italian food, which Aussie Siri isn’t actually capable of doing. Nor are any of these references marked by an asterisk – there’s just a small disclaimer at the bottom of the Siri description page that says “features may vary by area”. What is should say is that businesses, maps and traffic are available in the United States only.
Don’t get us wrong, Siri is more sophisticated than any of the voice recognition technologies baked into other mobile platforms. For a start, it actually understands most of what we say, which is more than we can, er, say for any other voice technology we’ve tried, including Apple’s older Voice Command feature.
Siri’s artificial intelligence comes into play in its ability to translate plain English into actionable requests. You don’t need to use set phrases like you do in other mobile platforms; you can say “what’s the weather going to be like in Sydney on Friday?” or “what’s the forecast in four days time in Sydney”, and it’s smart enough to return the same result for both questions. It can access a variety of built-in apps like Phone, Messages, Reminders, Clock, Mail, Music, Weather and Calendar to do your bidding, and it responds to requests in much the same way that a ‘real’ personal assistant would by replying to requests with phrases like “let me check on that”, and “this might answer your question”, and asking for confirmation before sending text messages and email.
Just like a human personal assistant, Siri can also remember the people you have key relationships with. If you say “Call my girlfriend”, it’ll ask what your girlfriend’s name is, and once you specify that, it’ll ask whether you want it to remember that person as your girlfriend. From then on, any girlfriend-related requests will refer back to that person. But this doesn’t work for all contact databases. Our first setup, which synced Google Contacts to our iPhone through an Exchange setup, didn’t save any of our relationship mapping as the only fields supported were for assistant, spouse and boss; we had to transfer all of our contacts to iCloud before this worked properly.
Our main beef with Siri, apart from the lack of support for local businesses and mapping, is that it doesn’t consistently return useful information, which ultimately means we’re less likely to use it in the future over a standard text web search. Sometimes, it returns a detailed response from WolframAlpha, which usually answers the question (albeit in an overly scientific manner).
More times than that, however, it will return a prompt to search the web (a result we could’ve gotten to sooner by doing a simple web search to start with), or give one of several canned phrases like “Is that so” and “OK”. It’s also programmed to give cheeky responses to specific questions. Ask Siri “what’s the best smartphone”, and it’ll reply, “The one you’re holding”. Other humorous exchanges include:
Q: When does the iPhone 5 come out?
A: Everything you need to know about Apple products is at Apple’s web site
Q: Will you marry me?
A: My End User Licensing Agreement does not cover marriage. My apologies.
Q: What is the meaning of life?
- A: Try and be nice to people, avoid eating fat, read a good book every now and then, get some walking in, and try to live together in peace and harmony with people of all creeds and nations.
- A: I can’t answer that right now, but give me some time to write a very long play in which nothing happens
- A: That’s easy… it’s a philosophical question concerning the purpose and significance of life or existence in general.
There’s also a new dictation feature into the software keyboard, but this seems to doesn’t seem to be any more accurate than other voice dictation technologies. We dictated the following phrase into an email: “Hi Mark. Can you check whether Andre got that report by the 12pm deadline? If not, I’ll have to see whether the suppliers can push the start date back by a week. Cheers, Arthur.” Siri returned “Hi mom can you check with Andrea got that report by the talking deadline if not I’ll have to say what the supplies to push the stop date back by wake cheese office”. By comparison, speaking the same phrase into an Android smartphone running 2.3.3 returned the following: “hi mark can you check when I get up at 5 o’clock pm deadline is not a good day weather wise got it back by a week cheer up”.
The strange thing is, doing the same thing via Siri, by preceding the phrase with “Send Mark an email”, returned much better results. It opened the Mail app, inputted the following phrase into the body of the email, “Hi Mark can you check weather Andre got that report at 12PM deadline if not I’ll have to see whether the suppliers can push the start date back by week cheers after”, and asked me what the subject of the email should be.
There’s no denying that Siri is extremely clever, and it’ll only get better over time as Apple works out the kinks and improves and expands on the voice recognition capabilities. But is it worth upgrading just for that if you currently own an iPhone 4? We’re voting no. We’ll probably change our minds if/when local business and mapping is supported, but as it stands, it doesn’t offer enough right now to be genuinely useful.
Jenneth Orantia turned her back on a lucrative career in law to pursue her unhealthy obsession with consumer technology. She’s known for having at least half a dozen of the latest gadgets on her person at a time, and once won a bottle of Dom Perignon for typing 78WPM on a Pocket PC with a stylus.
Image credit: Dan Nolan
You mentioned some other voice apps; how did you find Siri compared with Google’s Voice Actions?
Google Voice Actions doesn’t have any AI at all – you have to say commands using a specific format or it won’t understand you. Saying “play The Killers Spaceman” will results in a web search for that phrase in Google – you have to say “listen to The Killers Spaceman” for it to launch the music player with that track.
Google Voice Actions lets you access local businesses and mapping data, but you have to specify the exact business name – you can’t say “what’s the number for a local Chinese restaurant”, or “where’s the nearest servo” like you can with the American Siri.
Accuracy in Google Voice Actions is decent if you’re referring to a limited database, such as a contacts list or a music library, and it seems pretty accurate for sending text messages. But it’s very hit or miss when it comes to navigation requests.
Just thought I would share what I have learnt:
* It’s just a beta, people in the USA are beta testing a little more than the rest of us
* Maps and Business data is coming for Australia in 2012 (according to Apple)
* It learns your voice and learns more about you so it can be more accurate as time goes on, this could explain the better email dictation second time
* You can help it learn faster by tapping words and correcting them
* When dictating you can say “quote, unquote, period, new line” etc to add those punctuations to your results
PS: can I play with it now? I don’t have one yet :P
Maybe when it’s not a beta any longer, it’ll be worthwhile for the rest of us?
Do you have a reference to Apple saying that maps and business data will be coming to Australia in 2012?
I did read that it’s meant to learn your voice and become more accurate as time goes on. Obviously I can’t test this now, but it will be interesting to see whether this does happen.
For the record, I tried the same phrase via dictation just now, and got this:
“Hi mom can you check with Andre got that report buttercup pm deadline is not I have to say that the supplies can push the start date back bye week cheese”
Via Siri, I got
“Highmark can you check that Andre got that report by the talking deadline is not after see whether the supplies can push the Stargate back by week cheers up”
I can’t see an option to correct misinterpreted words – how do you do this?
http://www.apple.com/iphone/features/siri-faq.html
Under “Which apps does Siri work with?” it states:
Maps and local search support will be available in additional countries in 2012.
Given that we’re one of the launch countries, it’s reasonable to expect we’ll be one of the first additional countries to get maps and local search.
As for correcting, I’m guessing any time the blue underline is there, it’s a word you can tap, but I haven’t used it yet, so only know that others have spoken about it.
Given Apple’s previous form with launching software iThings in Australia, I’m not going to have a stack of confidence in this timing until I see something actually land.
Hell, at least it’s better than Google, which often never launches stuff in Australia that the US has had for years.
Does anyone know when iOS will integrate Australian location with Siri?
I felt ripped off by siri being unable to search Aust businesses/maps etc. The advertising is clearly misleading! How do they het away with that!
Same robyn…
i guess they werent so lucky with the new ipad and 4G fiasco….
Very disappointing that Aust is left out and feel ripped off
Comments are closed.