Delicious/delimiterau
- Qantas tech exec shifts to Jetstar
- Zurich Australia leads regional thin client push
- Early investors drop Facebook
- Victoria kills HealthSMART IT project
- Woz not great - mUmBRELLA
- Santos' thin client starts big-data plans
- Nokia Lumia 800 revs up at Bridgestone
- Telstra privacy breach was 'one little oops'
- 'Battleground of the future' the focus of new agreement with US
- The rise of the vendor management office
News - Written by Renai LeMay on Thursday, February 4, 2010 13:17 - 0 Comments
Pirate Party, EFA hail ‘common sense’ victory
The Pirate Party Australia has welcomed iiNet’s internet piracy victory over a coalition of film and TV studios, describing it as “a victory for common sense”, while civil liberties group Electronic Frontiers Australia said sanity had prevailed.
Justice Cowdroy today handed iiNet a sound victory in the Australian ISP’s long-running battle against a coalition of film and television studios, finding that iiNet did not authorise copyright infringement carried out by its customers using the BitTorrent file-sharing platform.
“This is a good decision by Justice Cowdroy, and reflects that there is no legal basis or obligation for any ISP to act in the interest of copyright holders, or to expect that they should disconnect any entity upon allegation of infringement without judicial oversight and due process,” said Pirate Party Australia secretary Rodney Serkowkski.
In a statement, Serkowski said ISPs should be considered similar to a postal service — the data they carried should be considered private.
In a statement labelled “sanity prevails”, EFA chair Nic Suzor wrote that the verdict provided important certainty for ISPs in Australia that the provision of internet access was not the means to infringe copyright.
“It also seems that more generally, this has important ramifications for innovation in Australia; in contrast with Kazaa, if you provide facilities that assist in infringement, but do not have control and do not act in bad faith, you will not be liable for secondary copyright infringement,” Suzor wrote, noting the decision sounded like it was consistent with the theory of secondary copyright liability developed in the US case of Sony vs Universal.
“The lack of control over the system means that iiNet has no legal responsibility over its users, despite knowledge that some users are obviously infringing copyright,” he said.
Warning
However both the Pirate Party and the EFA warned of future action in the field. “Expect an appeal,” wrote Suzor.
And the Pirate Party pointed out that the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade was currently engaged in negotiations over the international Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA), which could result in ‘three strikes’ regulation towards those who infringe copyright online.
The party’s statement said it rejected any three strikes rule, saying it was unacceptable to disconnect entire households from the internet upon accusations from the content industry.
Image credit: Pirate Party Australia
Related posts:
- Pirate Party slams AFACT’s ISP “extortion”
- iiNet, Pirate Party slam AFACT political moves
- EFA, Pirate Party slam film industry lawsuit “extortion”
- Govt piracy move “completely unjustified”: Pirate Party
- Pirate Party opposes anti-piracy warning scheme
| Tweet | |
![]() |
Enterprise IT, News - May 22, 2012 16:18 - 0 Comments
Govt pushes ahead with cloud-sharing approach
More In Enterprise IT
- The ABC didn’t sack Bitcoin miner
- Victoria dumps HealthSMART e-health project
- HP completes giant new NSW datacentre
- Microsoft beats Salesforce to utility CRM deal
- NSW finalises colossal datacentre consolidation
News, Telecommunications - May 22, 2012 11:15 - 61 Comments
NBN here to stay under Coalition, says analyst
More In Telecommunications
- iiNet ramps up Internode digestion
- China concerned by Huawei NBN ban, says Bob Carr
- Parliament knocks back surveillance terms
- Evidence: Rural Australia is demanding the NBN
- Pristine Telstra network photos: We sourced our own
Gadgets, News - May 21, 2012 12:32 - 5 Comments
Galaxy S III listed for Telstra, Optus and Vodafone
More In Gadgets
- Will Telstra skip Nokia’s Lumia 900?
- New BlackBerry OS 7.1 hits Australia
- ASUS Transformer Pad tablet hits Australia
- HTC One XL on sale: Compatible with Telstra 4G
- Optus a “disgusting” company, says AFL chief
Reviews - May 7, 2012 18:16 - 2 Comments
Telstra Mobile Wi-Fi 4G: Review
More In Reviews
- Samsung Galaxy S III: Preview
- HTC Titan II 4G: Preview
- Nokia Lumia 710: Review
- Sony Xperia S: Review
- Samsung Omnia W: Review









sponsored post ING Direct recently implemented a private cloud solution to virtualise its entire banking platform, allowing it to provision a new copy of itself -- a so-called 'bank in a box' -- within minutes. 
Leave a Comment