• Enjoy the freedom to innovate and grow your business


    [ad] With Microsoft Azure you have hybrid cloud flexibility, allowing your platform to span your cloud and on premise data centre. Learn more at microsoftcloud.com.

  • IT Admin: No Time to Save Time?


    [ad] Do you spend too much time patching machines or cleaning up after virus attacks? With automation controlled from a central IT management console accessible anytime, anywhere – you can save time for bigger tasks. Try simple IT management from GFI Cloud and start saving time today!

  • Free Forrester analysis of CRM solutions


    [ad] In this 25 page report, independent analyst house Forrester evaluates 18 significant products in the customer relationship management space from a broad range of vendors, detailing its findings on how CRM suites measure up and plotting where they stand in relation to each other. Download it for free now.

  • Great articles on other sites
  • RSS Great articles on other sites


  • Reader giveaway: Google Nexus 5


    We’re big fans of Google’s Nexus line-up in general at Delimiter towers. Nexus 4, Nexus 7, Nexus 10 … we love pretty much anything Nexus. Because of this we've kicked off a new competition to give away one of Google’s new Nexus 5 smartphones to a lucky reader. Click here to enter.

  • Enterprise IT, News - Written by on Tuesday, January 8, 2013 13:55 - 7 Comments

    $180m Vic Ultranet project a complete failure

    burning-money

    news Victoria’s Auditor-General has published a damning report classifying the state’s $180 million Ultranet educational technology project as broadly a complete failure, with the project being hardly used by the state’s students and teachers and being delivered late, over budget and with significant contract probity issues.

    The project was first mooted in the middle of the last decade, with its 2007 business case (following an earlier trial) promoting it as having the capacity to deliver an “intuitive, student-centred electronic learning environment” that would allow teachers, students and staff to access curriculum content, records, student reports and community features. After an initial pilot in 2006, when the project was dubbed ‘Student@Centre’, the system was then deployed to all Victorian Government schools throughout 2010, on the back of a contract announced in June 2009 with IT services group CSG, which in 2008 bought CingleVue, another local firm specialising in implementing Oracle solutions in the education sector. The project was based on Oracle technology.

    In 2009, CSG said at the time that the Ultranet solution would be “truly world class”. Then-CSG chief executive Denis Mackenzie commented “This will be the first true enterprise solution deployed in P-12 education in Australia, and is one of the first systems in the world to offer such a high level of functionality to students, teachers, parents and administrators.”

    However, a report published in late December by the Victorian Auditor-General has found that the project has suffered myriad problems. For starters, the auditor wrote, the project as a whole was “poorly planned and implemented”. “None of its three business cases had a well thought out needs analysis or gave considered options to deliver the project. The various business cases did not answer the ‘Why invest?’ question for the Ultranet, nor did they provide a sound basis for the project’s approval,” the report states, noting that six years after its announcement, the Ultranet project had not delivered its main objectives.

    Furthermore, the project continues “despite advice from central agencies that it should cease or be delayed”, with Victoria’s education department apparently ignoring advice on the subject by the departments of the Premier and Treasury.

    “It is difficult to understand why the Ultranet procurement was able to proceed to contract execution, given the significant concerns raised by DPC and DTF, as well as the many adverse ratings that DEECD had received from various Gateway reviews since the project first commenced,” the report states. “Further, this audit detected a number of serious process and probity issues in relation to tendering and procurement for the Ultranet. DEECD has advised that it has commenced a number of actions and further detailed investigations in response to these matters.”

    The auditor wrote that they had little confidence that financial management practices relating to the project were sound. The project appears likely to have blown out in total cost to about $180 million — triple what it was initially expected to cost — and use of the project is declining, with on average, only 10 percent of students and 27 percent of teachers in Victoria logging on to the platform on a monthly basis from July 2011 through May 2012.

    The auditor-general recommended the state’s education department urgently develop a comprehensive strategy to deal with the implementation of learning technologies in schools, as well as urgently reviewing its investment in Ultranet — and considering whether to pursue legal action against CSG. One option is to scrap the project as a whole, while another is to continue to fund it and fix the issues.

    The Age newspaper has quoted Victorian Education Minister Martin Dixon as stating that the project was a failure of the previous Labor administration in Victoria and that he had had strong reservations about the project since the Coalition took power in the state in December 2010.

    The news comes as the Victorian Government is struggling with almost all of its major IT projects at the moment. In November 2011, the Victorian Ombudsman handed down one of the most damning assessments of public sector IT project governance in Australia’s history, noting total cost over-runs of $1.44 billion, extensive delays and a general failure to actually deliver on stated aims in 10 major IT projects carried out by the state over the past half-decade.

    In its its first response to the report, in June last year, Victoria appointed former South Australian whole of state government chief information officer Grantly Mailes, to lead a committee (VICTAC) to establish a new wide-ranging IT strategy to resolve Victoria’s ongoing problems with IT service and project delivery. It also appointed a high-level advisory committee led by Mailes which would provide advice on a new whole of government ICT strategy to rectify the ongoing problems.

    Mailes’ office recently released the draft of a new whole of government information and communications technology strategy, with which it aims to start addressing the extensive IT project and service delivery issues. Most of the other states are suffering similar problems with IT project governance and service delivery, with the worst problems likely being suffered in Queensland, where the state in mid-December last year appointed a royal commission into the payroll systems disaster at Queensland Health.

    opinion/analysis
    I’ve been harping on about this for several years now. State Government IT in Australia is an absolute catastrophe of epic proportions right now — billions of dollars being wasted, projects simply not delivering on their outcomes, colossal setbacks in public service delivery. This situation is most likely the biggest issue in enterprise IT in Australia right now, bar none.

    submit to reddit

    7 Comments

    You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.

    1. tinman_au
      Posted 08/01/2013 at 5:37 pm | Permalink |

      I didn’t know you smoked cigars Renai!! :p

      But seriously, there’s too much “we know what’s best for you” going on in IT at the moment and not enough “How can we help folks do things better/easier/faster”. IT needs to get back to client focused, and not “What is the best way to give me a job” focused. That super-duper system may sound great at meetings, but if no one wants to use it, it may as well just be a $180m pot-plant…

    2. Dan
      Posted 08/01/2013 at 11:45 pm | Permalink |

      As far as State IT disasters go this one has nothing on the Qld Health payroll fiasco in terms of cost blowout/fix up costs, but it looks like this one was 100% outsourced, which is a bit more of a concern. The Qld disaster was primarily of the States own internal IT department’s making

    3. Douglas
      Posted 09/01/2013 at 9:30 am | Permalink |

      Thanks for providing such good ongoing coverage of State and Fed Govt IT issues Renai.
      Oz Govt Depts can well and truly piss money against the wall with the best of them it seems.

      • Posted 09/01/2013 at 10:01 am | Permalink |

        No worries. It’s a huge issue — billions of dollars of taxpayer money are literally being thrown against the wall here — personally, I find it hard to believe at times that things are so bad. Taking this project as an example, right from the original contract there were probity issues, and things started going bad quickly. But the Education Dept concerned ignored advice about the situation and just let it get horribly out of control, wasting years and years and more than $100 million along the way, for a project which looks likely to ultimately be scrapped.

        This is very far from being a standout project in state government IT at the moment. In fact, I’d say Ultranet is very representative. And that’s a terrible state of affairs.

        • Northern Blue
          Posted 09/01/2013 at 10:33 am | Permalink |

          It is a huge issue because it is known. Public Sector problems are more visible as Auditor-Generals, oppositions, and the media are keener to pursue stories in this environment. But in truth these disasters also occur in the private sector only, and this is a personal observations, the malignant projects seem to be identified earlier and curtailed quicker. The few of these I’ve managed to encounter go along the path of ‘demote or sack the decision maker(s) that made the wrong decision and the other decision makers in the organisation will try harder not to be similarly rewarded’.

          • tinman_au
            Posted 11/01/2013 at 11:56 am | Permalink |

            Agree entirely with this.

            I suspect that this is the real reason contracts get done with “commercial in confidence” so often now days, if they knew they’d be on time, on budget and correct, they’d be plastering it in ads all over like companies used to do…

    4. Mike
      Posted 11/01/2013 at 9:48 am | Permalink |

      Speaking of State Government IT, where has HEALTHSMART gone? Current Victorian Government abanded the project last year, that is, it’s been renamed Health Shared Services and still running… ;-)




    Get our 'Best of the Week' newsletter on Fridays

    Just the most important stories, one email a week.

    Email address:


  • Most Popular Content


  • Six smart secrets for nurturing customer relationships
    [ad] Today, we are experiencing a world where behind every app, every device, and every connection, is a customer. Your customers will demand you to be where they and managing customer relationship is the key to your business’s growth. The question is where do you start? Click here to download six free whitepapers to help you connect with your customers in a whole new way.
  • Enterprise IT stories

    • NetSuite in whole of business TurboSmart deal turbosmart

      Business-focused software as a service giant NetSuite has unveiled yet another win with a mid-sized Australian company, revealing a deal with automotive performance products manufacturer Turbosmart that has seen the company deploy a comprehensive suite of NetSuite products across its business.

    • WA Health told: Hire a goddamn CIO already doctor

      A state parliamentary committee has told Western Australia’s Department of Health to end four years of acting appointments and hire a permanent CIO, in the wake of news that the lack of such an executive role in the department contributed directly to the fiasco at the state’s new Fiona Stanley Hospital, much of which has revolved around poorly delivered IT systems.

    • Former whole of Qld Govt CIO Grant resigns petergrant

      High-flying IT executive Peter Grant has left his senior position in the Queensland State Government, a year after the state demoted him from the whole of government chief information officer role he had held for the second time.

    • Hills dumped $18m ERP/CRM rollout for Salesforce.com hills

      According to a blog post published by Salesforce.com today, one of Ted Pretty’s first moves upon taking up managing director role at iconic Australian brand Hills in 2012 was to halt an expensive traditional business software project and call Salesforce.com instead.

    • Dropbox opens Sydney office koalabox

      Cloud computing storage player Dropbox has announced it is opening an office in Sydney, as competition in the local enterprise cloud storage market accelerates.

    • Heartbleed, internal outages: CBA’s horror 24 hours commbankatm

      The Commonwealth Bank’s IT division has suffered something of a nightmare 24 hours, with a catastrophic internal IT outage taking down multiple systems and resulting in physical branches being offline, and the bank separately suffering public opprobrium stemming from contradictory statements it made with respect to potential vulnerabilities stemming from the Heartbleed OpenSSL bug.

    • Android in the enterprise: Three Aussie examples from Samsung androidapple

      Forget iOS and Windows. Today we present three decently sized deployments of Android in the Australian market on Samsung’s hardware, which the Korean vendor has dug up from its archives over the past several years for us after a little prompting :)

    • Businesslink cancelled Office 365 rollout cancelled

      Microsoft has been on a bit of a tear recently in Australia with its cloud-based Office 365 platform, signing up major customers such as the Queensland Government, Qantas, V8 Supercars and rental chain Mr Rental. And it’s not hard to see why, with the platform’s hybrid cloud/traditional deployment model giving customers substantial options. However, as iTNews reported last week, it hasn’t been all plain sailing for Redmond in this arena.

    • Qld Govt inks $26.5m deal for Office 365 walker

      The Queensland State Government yesterday announced it had signed a $26.5 million deal with Microsoft which will gain the state access to Microsoft’s Office 365 software and services platform. However, with the deal not covering operating system licences and not being mandatory for departments and agencies, it remains unclear what its impact will be.

    • Hospital IT booking system ‘putting lives at risk’ doctor

      A new IT booking platform at the Austin Hospital and Olivia Newton-John Cancer and Wellness Centre in Melbourne is reportedly placing the welfare of patients with serious conditions at risk.

  • Enterprise IT, News - Apr 17, 2014 16:39 - 0 Comments

    NetSuite in whole of business TurboSmart deal

    More In Enterprise IT


    News, Telecommunications - Apr 17, 2014 11:01 - 140 Comments

    Turnbull lies on NBN to Triple J listeners

    More In Telecommunications


    Featured, Industry, News - Apr 17, 2014 9:28 - 1 Comment

    Campaign Monitor takes US$250m from US VC

    More In Industry


    Digital Rights, News - Apr 17, 2014 12:41 - 14 Comments

    Anti-piracy lobbyist enjoys cozy email chats with AGD Secretary

    More In Digital Rights