Oh I see, you are a ‘mind reader’, you can actually tell us what Turnbull thinks, he doesn’t actually have to say anything anymore, we just ask you.

Amazing.)

You should audition.

http://www.abc.net.au/iview/#/series/3327591

:)

you said Turnbull said it

Nope. I never said Turnbull said it. Please try to read and comprehend things correctly. I said Turnbull thinks it should be “demolished”. Note the quotation marks. They mean something. Everything he has said in the past points to that without him explicitly saying it. Thing is he has had to flip-flop on the issue due to the great progress NBNco have been making… Now you know why they are regarded as hypocrites. Glad we got that sorted…

So what you said was totally incorrect (again).

Nope. You just failed to understand the comment correctly. Thanks for stopping by.

“Mr Rabbitt told him to “demolish” the NBN… he’s not doing a very good job of it though, maybe he hates Mr Rabbitt???”

Oh the good old HC soft shoe shuffle, but that’s not what you said, you said Turnbull said it, he didn’t, in fact when Gillard came out and said that’s what the Coalition would do if they got into power Turnbull reiterated the point and said they would not demolish any NBN already built.

So what you said was totally incorrect (again).

Why do you care, blah blah blah more piffle piffle waffle

That’s right I don’t care, however we are trying to determine coalition policy on the NBN here, since we cant I can assume they are hypocrites until they clarify their position.

Where did Turnbull ever say he would demolish the NBN

Mr Rabbitt told him to “demolish” the NBN… he’s not doing a very good job of it though, maybe he hates Mr Rabbitt???

No quite the opposite in fact.

Sorry but the evidence speaks for itself. The Liberal party are hypocrites, if you can’t even recognise this it makes you an even bigger hypocrite.

I will let you get on with your picture pasting

Great. You are finally going to cease your incessant childish whining.

http://i.imgur.com/sDJ89.jpg

Where did Turnbull ever say he would demolish the NBN, that’s right he didn’t, he said the opposite in fact

Well, he was told to demolish the NBN by his boss, but in such a conflicted party as the Liberal Party, doing the opposite of what your boss tells you is probably perfectly acceptable.

“t makes no difference both are Liberal party members. As a Victorian voter who should I believe and who should I listen to?”

Why do you care, you are a rabid pro-NBN campaigner, you couldn’t give a toss what the state or Federal Coalition say about the NBN that would in anyway influence your locked in myopic position.
Labor could come out and say we miscalculated the NBN costing, it is actually going to be triple what we predicted, and take a decade longer to finish, you would just say that’s ok, it’s worth any price ‘cos I need my upload speed increased.

” Mal who thinks the NBN is a white elephant and should be “demolished”?”

Where did Turnbull ever say he would demolish the NBN, that’s right he didn’t, he said the opposite in fact but you know that, but never let the facts get in the way of spouting emotive no fact BS eh?

” The picture is valid and their hypocrisy has been exposed.”

No quite the opposite in fact.

” Thanks for stopping by.”

My pleasure, I will let you get on with your picture pasting, misquoting, inaccurate, myopic pro-NBN propaganda campaign.

Both those statements were made by the Victorian Liberal government. Neither of the statements in quotes are paraphrasing — they’re direct quotes from the Victorian Liberal Party.

see you can learn…!

so we have liberals and clayton liberals, is that what you are saying? and they can contradict each other (just as you do)…

rofl.

“Blatant hypocrisy: Victoria demands NBN “fair share”

So therefore Turnbull doesn’t have to speak up at all, giving your one sided biased and misleading Turnbull picture based forum thread a plug is one thing (I am sure the NBN converted appreciate the effort) but please try and least stay on topic when you do it.

Go to it, get some Rich-Phillips pics and insert statements he never actually said and when called out excuse it as ‘paraphrasing’.

Malcom Turnbull is not a MP in the Coalition Government of Victoria.

Their criticism isn’t hypocritical at all, you just don’t properly understand their position

http://i.imgur.com/7QWhJ.jpg

The fact that the Liberal government is complaining against this further strengthens one of their criticisms of NBN, its taking a dog and a half years to complete, and so there are going to be areas without any broadband improvement for a significant amount of time

Also you can’t really claim this is an issue with the state government, telecommunications infrastructure is owned by Telstra, and not by the state government, and the state government does not legally (or otherwise) have the same amount of muscle as the federal government

Their criticism isn’t hypocritical at all, you just don’t properly understand their position

i.e. Victoria is being treated as second class citizen.

its his argument and i personally think its horseshit. evidently you do too. but the fact is it buts right up against the liberal notion that NBN is something we can easily do without, or at the very least dial back to something less ambitious/spending less.

if its the former, then there is no reason to ask for expedited rollout in Vic – and hes being hypocritical. if its the latter i have to ask what his idea of ‘adequate’ services is. as you say Melbs has that 100mbit cable service; if that is considered inadequate mebbe hes thinking of the business Gbit services that NBN intend offering.

either way hes a rather confused man.

I didn’t bring up Coalition policy as being ‘patchwork and substandard’

Actually you did. I described their plan as a patchwork but rather than sticking to the topic at hand and what was contained in my comment you instead chose to focus on this one irrelevant issue. btw it’s not just my opinion that their plan is a mess and a substandard patchwork, it is a fact. Get over it.