Delicious/delimiterau
- Earning billions and getting taxed a pittance
- Dell chief defends transfer pricing
- Qantas tech exec shifts to Jetstar
- Zurich Australia leads regional thin client push
- Early investors drop Facebook
- Victoria kills HealthSMART IT project
- Woz not great - mUmBRELLA
- Santos' thin client starts big-data plans
- Nokia Lumia 800 revs up at Bridgestone
- Telstra privacy breach was 'one little oops'
Featured, News - Written by Renai LeMay on Monday, July 26, 2010 14:04 - 2 Comments
Ballarat’s BitTorrent study “horribly wrong” says TorrentFreak
Global BitTorrent news source TorrentFreak has ridiculed the veracity of a study on the legality of BitTorrent usage published by the University of Ballarat last week, labelling some of its claims “horribly wrong” and that “mistake after mistake” was made during its preparation.
In the report, the university’s Internet Commerce Security Laboratory (ICSL) claimed that 89 percent of BitTorrent files it studied during a certain period, using the Torrentz.com search engine – were confirmed to infringe copyright. The research was publicised to the press last week by the Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft as a victory in its ongoing war against file sharing.
But TorrentFreak – one of the globe’s most well-known sources of BitTorrent news, with 190,000 RSS followers, said in its own analysis of the report that its “conclusions are drawn based on painfully inaccurate data and methodologies”.
TorrentFreak editor in chief Ernesto claimed that ICSL was wrong about:
- Its claim that there was more than one million torrent files to be found online (Ernesto claimed some sites – such as isoHunt – indexed more than 5 million)
- Its claim that there were about 117 million BitTorrent seeds (Ernesto estimated this number at between 10 and 20 million)
- Its claim that the most seeded file, The Incredible Hulk film, had 1.1 million seeds (Ernesto said the best-seeded torrent at the moment only had 13,738 seeders)
And finally, Ernesto slammed ICSL’s overall conclusion that almost all files on BitTorrent infringed copyright, with only a small percentage confirmed legal. “This statistic is grossly inaccurate, because it’s based on the most popular files, of which many are fake,” they wrote. “Bottom line is that this ‘Academic’ paper is one of the most inaccurate reports we’ve seen thus far.”
University of Ballarat associate professor Paul Watters – who, along with research student Robert Layton, authored the report – has not yet responded to a request for comment about TorrentFreak’s claims.
The news comes as the court struggle continues between AFACT and iiNet over whether and to what extent the ISP is responsible for its customers infringing copyright by downloading content through BitTorrent. This morning, the AustralianIT reported that the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance had asked to be heard in the case as a friend of the court.
Image credit: Sias van Schalkwyk, royalty free
Related posts:
- Ballarat Uni claims 89% of BitTorrent is illegal
- AFACT issues BitTorrent warning to ISPs
- Secret BitTorrent agreement on the cards
- AFACT wants ‘automated’ BitTorrent violation system
- Attorney-General’s Dept seeks BitTorrent advice
| Tweet | |
![]() |
2 Comments
Leave a Comment
Enterprise IT, Featured, News - May 23, 2012 12:54 - 0 Comments
SAP’s SuccessFactors deploys Aussie datacentre
More In Enterprise IT
- Govt pushes ahead with cloud-sharing approach
- The ABC didn’t sack Bitcoin miner
- Victoria dumps HealthSMART e-health project
- HP completes giant new NSW datacentre
- Microsoft beats Salesforce to utility CRM deal
Analysis, Telecommunications - May 23, 2012 11:08 - 5 Comments
The NBN, service providers and you … what could go wrong?
More In Telecommunications
- NBN here to stay under Coalition, says analyst
- iiNet ramps up Internode digestion
- China concerned by Huawei NBN ban, says Bob Carr
- Parliament knocks back surveillance terms
- Evidence: Rural Australia is demanding the NBN
Gadgets, News - May 21, 2012 12:32 - 5 Comments
Galaxy S III listed for Telstra, Optus and Vodafone
More In Gadgets
- Will Telstra skip Nokia’s Lumia 900?
- New BlackBerry OS 7.1 hits Australia
- ASUS Transformer Pad tablet hits Australia
- HTC One XL on sale: Compatible with Telstra 4G
- Optus a “disgusting” company, says AFL chief
Reviews - May 7, 2012 18:16 - 2 Comments
Telstra Mobile Wi-Fi 4G: Review
More In Reviews
- Samsung Galaxy S III: Preview
- HTC Titan II 4G: Preview
- Nokia Lumia 710: Review
- Sony Xperia S: Review
- Samsung Omnia W: Review









sponsored post ING Direct recently implemented a private cloud solution to virtualise its entire banking platform, allowing it to provision a new copy of itself -- a so-called 'bank in a box' -- within minutes. 
Who funded the study?
In other breaking news, the entire prison population of the Universe has claimed they are innocent. “It was the Linux ISO who dunnit your honour!!! And who’s paying my bus fare home??”